18+ Easter Egg Filler Ideas

​Are you stumped for ideas on what to put in plastic Easter eggs? Looking to make your egg hunt just a little more fun and exciting?

Awesome! Coz today I'm going to share over eighteen different things you can put in a plastic Easter egg!

Can I confess something really silly to you? Don't laugh...but I love plastic Easter eggs. I still get excited when I see them in the stores, even though Easter is not really one of my favorite holidays. 

Since it almost always rains here on Easter, I tend to buy (way too many) plastic eggs as back-up for our egg hunt.

I learned the hard way that rain+egg dye+white frilly Easter dresses=big mess/sad mom. 

But since plastic eggs don't have anything good inside, like say...egg, then it makes sense to fill them up ourselves. (Not with egg.) 

Plus, by filling the eggs, you can actually save a little money on Easter baskets by making customized ones from things I KNOW my kids will like for more than five minutes. 
​
If you put the smaller prizes and treats inside the eggs, you have more space in your basket for larger, substantial items such as books. 

​"Secret" prizes make the Easter baskets and egg-hunt much more exciting! 

Okay. So here are some of my tried-and-true, kid approved egg filler ideas: 

1. Money

​Not really a new idea. But we like to put a dollar in the "prize" egg, and a few smaller coins in some of the other eggs. That way everyone gets some, ya know. 

​2. Candy

Well obviously, right? Okay, some people don't like giving candy to their kids, and that's okay. I'm the bad mom that doesn't mind candy, but my girls aren't that wild about it anyhow.

Rather than holiday themed chocolates that melt in rain (or sun), I've found that things like caramel cubes, Tootsie rolls, and small pouches of fruit snacks hold up better. 

(I save the chocolate for after those frilly dresses come off!) 

If you are really against candy, I'm sure dried fruit, would work too! 

3. Party Beads

​My girls love those cheap strands of dress-up beads from the party section. They are 4 for $1 at Walmart and some of the dollar stores, and they fit nicely in a regular sized egg. 

(They also look very festive looped around a small Easter tree display.)

4. Toy Cars
​

You might have to go up an egg size depending on the car, but the die-cast cars are usually a dollar or less and can provide fun play-time for months or years. 

5. Play-Doh

You can buy the eggs that have Play Doh already inside, or you can save a little money by stuffing your own. 

I recommend taking it out of the eggs as soon as possible though, because for some reason, all Easter eggs have "breathing holes" and you don't want the Play Doh to dry out. 

Personally, I love this idea because it gives kids something to do after the egg hunt is over. You can get creative by adding some glitter or even hiding more small prizes inside the dough! You can  make and dye your own dough to have holiday themed colors. 

6. Lip Gloss
​

​Big eggs can hold a tube or two of lip gloss. Several small pots of gloss can be stacked into an egg.

If you don't have a lip gloss addict, then small pots of colored body glitter will fit too. 

7. Nail Polish 

​Those tiny bottles of nail polish you find in the kid's section will fit into an egg! So will those small sheets of nail stickers. And it's the perfect time of the year to find pastels and glitter polishes. 

8. Legos

You can't fit a whole set of Legos into one egg...but you CAN split a set between all the eggs. Now, how fun is that? 

If you have a Lego lover in your house, this is a great way to surprise them with a new play set. 

9. Doll and Small Figurines
​

​Smallish toy figures fit into larger eggs. My girls are Little People fanatics, and I try to find a new set of dolls or an animal to give them for special occasions. A Little People doll will fit into a larger easter egg. 

These Disney Toddler Princesses also fit, as well as a variety of superhero figures, Minions, ponies and other small dolls. 

For older children, those tiny collectible toys like Shopkins could be a fun egg filler. 

​10. Sticker Sheets

Dollar stores always have tons of sticker sheets. If you trim off the paper around the stickers, the sheet can be rolled carefully and tucked into an egg. 

You can also buy a sheet or roll of stickers and cut off smaller sections for each egg. 

11. Temporary Tattoos

These can also be bought in booklets or on sheets. They can be trimmed small enough to fit in an egg. 

There are thousands of fun designs, and even grown-ups can enjoy them. 

12. Mini Sharpie Markers

For doodling on your plastic eggs after the egg hunt. Then save your works of art to hunt again next year. 

13. Beading or Bracelet Kit

Have a crafty kid? A roll of that plastic lacing and enough pony beads for a bracelet will fit into an egg. So will floss for making braided friendship bracelets. 

This is another fun way to spend the afternoon after the hunt. 

14. Balloons

If every single egg had a balloon in it, my kids would be happy.

Luckily, you can get big bags of balloons everywhere for practically nothing.  (And you can squish bunches of them into an egg!)

15. Confetti!
​
Fill eggs with glitter and confetti and encourage an egg fight. Your yard will never look prettier!

16. Miniature Cards

Instead of a full size Easter card in their basket, craft a tiny, custom card with a special message and hide it in an egg. You could also make small, personalized books. 

17. Small Novelty Toys

Big goodie bags of "gumball" machine toys are instant winners with children. Some of the items that will fit into eggs include: 
​

• Tops
• Rubber stamps
• Rubber balls
• Small lights
• Glow in the dark animals/insects
• Mini-kaleidoscopes
• Bendable figures
• Finger puppets
• Whistles
• Jacks
• Sticky hands
• Gummy stickers
• Gummy animals

18. Flower Seeds

For only a few cents at any store, you can buy numerous packs of flowers that are easy for kids to grow. Some easy kid flowers include: 
​

• Zinnias
• Daisies
• Marigolds
• Nasturtiums
• Cosmos
• Sunflowers
• Wildflower mixes

Simply roll and tuck the packet into an egg. For seed mixes, you can later help your child turn the egg into a seed shaker (drill or poke some larger holes). 

Once they are ready for gardening, just shake the seeds onto the ground. (much easier than getting them out of those paper packs!) 

If you wanted to be hilarious, you could always use eggplant seeds...

Bonus Ideas: 

UPDATED! Now that my kids are a bit older (7 and 4), here some other ideas for Easter egg fillers I've figured out: 

• Small pencil sharpeners
• ​Novelty erasers
• Barbie accessories
• Tiny My Little Pony figurines
• Small pin-back buttons
• Earrings
• Hair ties
• Soft head bands
• Ear bud headphones 
• Keychain size emery boards
• "Coupons" or IOUs for treats/day out

Have fun filling all those eggs!

*Post may contain affiliate links. When you buy or sign up using my links, I earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Full disclosure here*